Our Story

Maggies cookie Jar is the BEST!

Maggies Ice Cream is nice and clean. They offer a good selection of ice creams, along with ice cream cakes, pies, and truffles. The ice cream was good and reminded me (flavor and texture) of blue bell ice cream.
Entrees: (1) 2 scoop: Seasalt and some coffee flavor (2) 2 Scoop: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and Moose tracks
Atmosphere/Decor: Clean, basic design. A bit narrow on space, definetly more of a to-go place.
Service: Friendly
Food Wait: Quick
Cost/Value: $5 per person/Good Price.

They make their own waffle cones and chocolate dip them in house! Tons of homemade flavors! :D

Great selection, very clean, great service, and delicious ice cream. I had a brownie sundae and it was everything I thought it would be

SOOOO good. We are pretty picky when it comes to ice cream. They have some unique flavors I've never heard of if you're in the mood to explore something non standard and the typical flavors are great. Overall, exceptional ice cream and reasonable prices. Wish they were open later though.

Came here during our honeymoon.... best toasted coconut ice cream I’ve ever had!!!!

Can't say enough wonderful things about Maggie's! Friendly and helpful folks working there with some of the most fabulous ice cream ever! Beautiful, clean and happy atmosphere! Will definitely recommend and definitely looking forward to going back!

Delicious ice cream and tons of classic and interesting flavors! The Oreo/cookie dough was yummy and so was the maple chocolate bacon! Delicious waffles cones too.

They have a variety of interesting and rich flavors at a great price

nice

The grape nut ice cream is to die for…and always excellent service

Strawberry is very, very berry!

Loved their selection of ice cream flavors...satisfied with my black cherry flavor.....so many pieces of fresh black cherries in my scoop

This place is awesome. It is real real hard to find a good milkshake,but they our able to make it the perfect fit of consistency but not super thick you can't drink it. Ice cream is awesome as well.

The girls were so nice here! The ice cream was awesome too, want to come back and try some of the fun ice cream tacos they have soon

My kids have been waiting for Maggies to open and it was worth the wait. We have been there twice now and both times the staff have been very friendly. They have a lot of flavors to choose from and all the ones we have tried so far have been very good. They let you sample flavors if you like. My daughter had an ice cream sandwich which she devoured.

Amazing! So many flavors. Very clean

Superb, extremely high quality ice cream & very friendly people. Worth a try, specially the german chocolate cake ice cream.
Will definitely come again!

The ice cream was oh so good. Lots of choices to get your taste buds satisfied. The team was ready to serve. You will not be disappointed when you stop!

Maggie's Ice Cream Shop is awesome! They are very friendly and helpful, the shop is spotless and decorated in such a fun way. Most of all, the ice cream is delicious!! I highly recommend Maggie's Ice Cream Shop!

My kids have been waiting for Maggies to open and it was worth the wait. We have been there twice now and both times the staff have been very friendly. They have a lot of flavors to choose from and all the ones we have tried so far have been very good. They let you sample flavors if you like. My daughter had an ice cream sandwich which she devoured. I only wish they had more seating inside. We like to sit and enjoy our ice cream and currently they only have 2 small benches inside.

Oh! The ice cream is the best I have ever had! The chocolate dipped waffle cones are divine! The staff there are all very friendly! They honored my military service with a 20% discount.

The ice cream is made locally. My favorite is the coffee bean ice-cream and Rocky road in a chocolate dipped waffle cone! Yum!

The hours are the best! Thank you for your great ice cream! You are a wonderful addition to the community!

They got damn good ice cream, you should go!

Really a fun and friendly place for some delicious ice cream. Their ice cream is cold but their staff and environment will warm your heart with a good comfort of home. They will treat you right and take any order to make your ice cream the best ice cream you every had. Multiple toppings and flavors to choose from that the combinations are endless, definitely worth a stop to try it out for yourself!

Delicious ice cream and very cute and clean shop. Not sure well be back though because there is no seating which makes it impossible with kids. You cant really eat ice cream to go in the car because of the mess. Seating and a place to wash off little ones after they eat would be great. Otherwise its an awesome place.

Great ice cream, wonderful service. I recommend this place to anyone who loves ice cream

Friendly staff. I was not too impressed by the icecream. We will try again.

Googled homemade ice cream and Maggie's came up, so off we went! The employees all 3 were absolutely sweet. Now the ice cream.....delicious!!!! and I asked if they could make one of our favorites and it was without a second of hesitation and YES was the answer.
We cant wait till stop in again!

Seriously the most unique flavors around! We absolutely love the Tiramisu and Banana Pudding.

As an ice cream connoisseur, I have personally tried 1000s of flavors of ice cream from around the world. If we are talking about ice cream alone and not gelato. Then I would rank their ice cream making process in the top 10 in the United States and by far the best I have had in Florida. I have no affiliation with Maggie's but just want to see a good business that is bettering their community strive with their rich flavors and great customer service.

Can't resist passing Maggie's whenever I am in the Suntree area. Variety of flavors & choices. Staff & owner are so nice, helpful & patient. Can't always decide what to choose. Both soft ice cream & hard creamy as well as cookies & cakes. Glad there's a rewards program

The quality of ice cream here is astounding. You can taste the care and fine ingredients that went into making their products. I've traveled the world and had a lot of great desserts; this parlour can compete with the best of them. Not only that, the whimsical atmosphere and friendly staff really make the experience a memorable one. Keep up the good work!

I couldn't believe this was the only location, it's the best ice cream store I've ever been. Moo's? Forget about it. Ben & Jerry's? Not good enough anymore. Coldstone? You've gotta be kidding me! This place designs its own flavors. It's amazing!

The new Blueberry Cheesecake ice cream flavor alone should've been Time's Person of the Year. I stumbled across this place with my family, and we all walked out with a new all-time favorite ice cream flavor. You owe it to yourself to sample the blueberry cheesecake and strawberry shortcake ice cream flavors. The cones are freshly made and spectacular as well!

I sincerely hope you'll be hearing more about Maggie's in the future. It's too good not to explode into popularity soon.

Fantastic place, ice cream is great and very affordable. The price was so good that I thought they missed an item from my order!

So good! The texture of the ice cream is so smooth and creamy! And all the ice cream is homemade Well definitely be coming back!

We enjoyed your ice cream!

Amazing icecream Awesome and very welcoming staff very friendly

Phenomenal ice cream. Take the family, you wont be disappointed.

We had the Mississippi Mud Pie and the chocolate chip cookie.

Great variety and cleanliness. Super friendly too.

Pretty great milkshake

Friendly staff and the ice-cream is delicious and made on site.

Great handmade ice cream alot of flavors and awesome staff always great service

Great ice cream and friendly service. My favorite!

Phenomenal icecream and lovely place! I've lived here for 20 years and this is one of the best places I've tried and will certainly be coming back. Very clean, lots of flavors, and the staff was very pleasant to talk to.

Such a cute shop! The staff and owner were incredibly helpful and super nice. A+ for customer relations. The ice cream was great too. There is nothing like homemade icecream! We'll definitely be back!

Ice cream is delicious and lots of toppings. The ice cream is not too sweet where it blends in with toppings.

Excellent service and good prices. Clean and safe. Loved the waffle bowls!

Excellent ice cream, service and very friendly

Great staff and icecream what more could you want?!?!

Well worth the drive. We live in SE Palm Bay, and since he left this area and went to this new location, we haven't been satisfied with anything around here. So we make the trip north for the best ice cream ever. AWESOME Selection.

Cute small Ice Cream shop with an excellent selection of flavors ice cream and Italian ice. Plus they have shakes, malts, cups, sundaes, cake cones, sugar cones, waffle cones, ice cream pies, ice cream tacos, ice cream cannolis, and chocolate covered bananas. Highly recommend! Great dessert and great service!

OMG!!! The best hom made ice cream and more! Friendly people!!! Got to try it!!!

Amazing fresh in store made ice cream. Literally everything is delicious. Close your eyes and randomly point at the menu and say Ill have that and you wont be disappointed.

Very good ice cream with lots of different flavors. Kids enjoyed it too!

Amazing Ice Cream, didn't care for the waffle cone however, otherwise it would have gotten a 5!

Great ice cream!!! Excellent customer service!! Only downfall was the waffle cone, otherwise 5 stars!

Great local homemade ice cream. Ever changing flavors, they will even customize one for you. Fresh and crunchy waffle cone held my "medium" size three flavors: toasted coconut, mint (Dark) chip and Viera's Delight special (caramel and fudge in vanilla ice cream with m&ms). Friendly and fast service. They offer tastes before choosing.

Great

Yummy ice cream and very kind staff!

Fantastic ice cream and nice people too!

The best ice cream! Super clean establishment and great staff.

Very delicious homemade ice cream! Very friendly staff! I Would definitely recommend

The soft serve is very creamy. Thick and very tasty! Waiting for their freezers to get fixed to try their scoop ice cream

The best and service is outstanding

Very creamy and tasty. Good selection of standard flavors and a couple unique ones. They have amazing soft serve too!

Clean and large variety of favorite ice cream.

Delicious ice cream. And they make their own ice cream. So good!

There ice cream here is delicious. I live close by and always come out at night to get some ice cream. Its delicious and relaxing outside on the outdoor tables. Everyone is friends and delicious ice cream on a hot day! Cant complain. Would definitely recommend

Best ice cream around! Lovely friendly staff. Amazing sundaes.

This place was so good!!! My family and I decided to do a little night out, while still trying to be safe during Covid-19 times. We attempted to hit up cold stone and they were packed!!! No attempts to social distance. So we sadly were on our way home when we saw Maggie's sign. I'm so glad we stopped here!! It was busy, but not unsafe, it was super clean (like Godly clean), and the staff was so so sweet!! They let you try different flavors and explained all their different goodies. The ice cream was so good! Can't wait to come back here again. :)

Face mask wearing required. Associates were friendly and courteous. The on premise made ice cream was awesome. 20% Military discount offered and appreciated. Highly recommend eating here. We will be back.

Ordered a custom ice cream sheet cake for our daughters birthday with Smurf Ice cream and Cake Batter Ice cream layers and it was WONDERFUL! Not only was the ice cream delicious but the decoration of the cake was amazing. We were very pleased. The adults enjoyed the flavors of ice cream as much as the kids, maybe more. This is our 2nd ice cream cake from Maggies and is now our "go to" for birthday cakes! Price is very reasonable as well! Highly recommend!

My brownie sundae was creamy, chocolaty and delicious. The fudge was hot and satisfying. I recommend this to all my friends.

My husband & I make our weekly date out to Maggie’s. We love all of their flavors. However our 2 best are salted caramel & black cherry. Oh Soo good. We always go home with a pint of both
Great staff are like family. Love visiting to discover new flavors. You owe a treat To yourself & friends to real non- chemically made ice cream at the local grocery store

Maggie’s is such a fun spot! The staff is amazing and so kind. The ice cream is super creamy and delicious! We can’t wait to go back!

Absolutely the BEST!! Thanks!

This place is absolutely addictive! It has by far the freshest and delicious ice cream I have ever had! And I am an ice cream Nazi.

I stopped in Maggie’s Ice cream shop today because I was having a bad day and I have been wanting to try this place. I got a little soft serve for my pup in the car and this incredible chocolate peanut butter swirl ice cream that was delicious!!! Maggie’s was just what we needed something sweet to change our mood. The best, creamiest ice cream I think I’ve ever had. Is it too soon to go back??

1st time here! It was a very cute and quiet store with many flavors to choose from. I got 2 scoops, 1 pb cookie dough & 1 Maggie's cookie (something like that) and they were both delicious! The staff was smiling, friendly and polite! The also have shakes, ice cream cakes, cookie sandwiches and waffle bowls. Note: there isn't any tables and/or chairs to sit and eat after you've ordered! If that's important to you, you might want to consider going elsewhere. We are ours in the car and didn't mind!

Just had it for the first time gotta day the best peanut butter ice cream I've ever had in this county. The owner was friendly as well as the staff and the place is fun with its color scheme. With the latest technology of displaying all there flavors on iPads this place really has it going on! I give it a 5 star.

First time here tonight. Kids wanted the other place in the Avenues but I wanted to try the local spot. Granted, I had no idea it was even open yet. Ice cream blows doors on the chain place and is a little cheaper. Will frequent this place. Many different flavors to choose from. Service was great.

We went into this new ice cream shop and was greeted by friendly staff and helpful. We were offered samples before purchasing our ice cream. Had many flavors and choices.

My kids have been waiting for Maggie’s to open and it was worth the wait. We have been there twice now and both times the staff have been very friendly. They have a lot of flavors to choose from and all the ones we have tried so far have been very good. They let you sample flavors if you like. My daughter had an ice cream sandwich which she devoured. I only wish they had more seating inside. We like to sit and enjoy our ice cream and currently they only have 2 small benches inside.

Our first time here. I had a scoop of the Lemon Raspberry and my hunny had a scoop of Maple Walnut. Both were so yummy! I did notice they didn't have tables but small benches to sit on.

Maggie's is an excellent ice cream shop. My family is visiting this week from Chicago and Maggie's stands up to some of the best independent ice cream shops in the Windy City. The service was also great...when we were in, there were probably 4-5 high school or college aged kids working and they were just so friendly and had great attitudes. The store itself is bright, clean, and inviting. The ice cream was delicious. We tried several flavors and the ones that stood out were the cake batter, toasted coconut, German chocolate cake, and black cherry. This place just opened in July, so really hoping the locals embrace this gem of an old school ice cream shop. I'll be back every time I visit my parents!

This is the perfect place to go if you're looking for great homemade ice cream. The staff is super friendly and helpful. The shop was very inviting and bright. The ice cream was excellent! They have a lot of selections to choose from along with some daily special ice creams. Overall it was a great experience. Definitely will be coming back!

Maggie's is awesome. The staff is very friendly. The flavors are unique, and made in house. I sampled a pineapple-upside down cake ice cream that was amazing. They also offer a military discount which is always nice.