Our Story

This place is absolutely addictive! It has by far the freshest and delicious ice cream I have ever had! And I am an ice cream Nazi.

I stopped in Maggie’s Ice cream shop today because I was having a bad day and I have been wanting to try this place. I got a little soft serve for my pup in the car and this incredible chocolate peanut butter swirl ice cream that was delicious!!! Maggie’s was just what we needed something sweet to change our mood. The best, creamiest ice cream I think I’ve ever had. Is it too soon to go back??

1st time here! It was a very cute and quiet store with many flavors to choose from. I got 2 scoops, 1 pb cookie dough & 1 Maggie's cookie (something like that) and they were both delicious! The staff was smiling, friendly and polite! The also have shakes, ice cream cakes, cookie sandwiches and waffle bowls. Note: there isn't any tables and/or chairs to sit and eat after you've ordered! If that's important to you, you might want to consider going elsewhere. We are ours in the car and didn't mind!

Just had it for the first time gotta day the best peanut butter ice cream I've ever had in this county. The owner was friendly as well as the staff and the place is fun with its color scheme. With the latest technology of displaying all there flavors on iPads this place really has it going on! I give it a 5 star.

First time here tonight. Kids wanted the other place in the Avenues but I wanted to try the local spot. Granted, I had no idea it was even open yet. Ice cream blows doors on the chain place and is a little cheaper. Will frequent this place. Many different flavors to choose from. Service was great.

We went into this new ice cream shop and was greeted by friendly staff and helpful. We were offered samples before purchasing our ice cream. Had many flavors and choices.

My kids have been waiting for Maggie’s to open and it was worth the wait. We have been there twice now and both times the staff have been very friendly. They have a lot of flavors to choose from and all the ones we have tried so far have been very good. They let you sample flavors if you like. My daughter had an ice cream sandwich which she devoured. I only wish they had more seating inside. We like to sit and enjoy our ice cream and currently they only have 2 small benches inside.

Our first time here. I had a scoop of the Lemon Raspberry and my hunny had a scoop of Maple Walnut. Both were so yummy! I did notice they didn't have tables but small benches to sit on.

Maggie's is an excellent ice cream shop. My family is visiting this week from Chicago and Maggie's stands up to some of the best independent ice cream shops in the Windy City. The service was also great...when we were in, there were probably 4-5 high school or college aged kids working and they were just so friendly and had great attitudes. The store itself is bright, clean, and inviting. The ice cream was delicious. We tried several flavors and the ones that stood out were the cake batter, toasted coconut, German chocolate cake, and black cherry. This place just opened in July, so really hoping the locals embrace this gem of an old school ice cream shop. I'll be back every time I visit my parents!

This is the perfect place to go if you're looking for great homemade ice cream. The staff is super friendly and helpful. The shop was very inviting and bright. The ice cream was excellent! They have a lot of selections to choose from along with some daily special ice creams. Overall it was a great experience. Definitely will be coming back!

Maggie's is awesome. The staff is very friendly. The flavors are unique, and made in house. I sampled a pineapple-upside down cake ice cream that was amazing. They also offer a military discount which is always nice.